The wording of the poll was designed with that in mind—it refers to “the current Supreme Court,” but not Davis v. Ermold. You should vote “yes” if you think the current Court—i.e., this set of justices—will overrule Obergefell.
Greetings! Much appreciate your post and you, as always, presenting cleanly arguments from both sides. Much of the media and legal publications these days take pleasure in delivering sound-bites / outrage to energize their active base, rather than deliver the facts as they are. Yet, putting that to the side, Obergefell very likely will not, and should not, be overruled in this case. I am not yet an attorney, but I am wondering how / to what extent justice Kennedy's recent comments on his book tour still stand and have purchase with the justices (reliance plus societal impact?) Plus, isn't there an issue here with the equal protection clause as well?
While I am here, I am also troubled with another part of question 3 in this petition, the "fiction" of substantive due process. If Kim Davis really wants Obergefell to be throne out, is it truly tactful to add such loaded terms into the question presented? Contrast that wording there to this: "Whether all pre-viability prohibitions on elective abortions are unconstitutional Take that for what it is, and what resulted.
Finally, unlike in the pre-dobbs landscape, has there been any movement by state legislatures (save Idaho) to express objection to Obergefell? At the very least, one can and did argue that red states had weighed in strongly in opposition to Roe / Casey before they were tossed. Has the same happened here?
In closing, I do wish that certain media outlets would take more time to study SCOTUS procedure / filings. I fear that an ignorance of such issues, plus a need to get more views, ratings and clicks, causes the media to craft provocative headlines on this issue that distort what is actually happening. Thank you.
Agree with John that Obergefell was wrongly and tendentiously decided, but the current Court will not want to waste any legitimacy on a question that has been decided in the court of public opinion and will likely deny cert. on the petition as a whole without comment.
Except that at the times Dobbs was decided at least 2/3 of the public approved of legal abortion. The court had no trouble then of dismissing public opinion.
The grant rate for a regular cert petition hovers around 1%. When a response has been called for it raises to 5%. Still vanishingly small.
I just don’t see how to count to the four necessary to grant cert here. I do see five plus to decide the question differently as a matter of first principles, but that ship has sailed. On top of the question of whether to take the case, I don’t know if there are five to overrule Obergefell. I could easily see the liberals convincing at least two, maybe three, to leave it in place.
That’s cold comfort to my friends experiencing serious turmoil whose marriages would be imperiled by a grant. But I just don’t see it happening.
In addressing Big Questions, I tend to look from 3 angles:
1. Policy: what would be a good rule, and who gets to decide?
2. Legal/constitutional: what does existing law say, and who gets to decide?
3. Political: what will the public demand, accept, or reject?
All 3 are relevant, but should be considered separately, and point to the appropriate path to making a decision.
With respect to policy, I think allowing same-sex marriage is good, because I return to first principles: the (only) reason for the civil institution of marriage is to provide a legal framework for raising and supporting children. Although same-sex couples can't have their own biological children, they can (and do) have children by various other means: artificial insemination, surrogacy, and adoption for instance. It is in everyone's interest - the couples, the children, the larger society, to allow these couples to formalize their relationship and the attendant rights and responsibilities.
With respect to law, I think there's no good-faith argument that pre-Obergefell law required recognition of same-sex marriage nationwide, particularly as the federal government has no role in marriage law. I think there is a very strong argument that the "full faith and credit" clause (Article 4, section 1) of the US Constitution would require all states to recognize same-sex marriages performed and recorded in other states; this would have similar practical effect to Obergefell, but entirely different reasoning.
With respect to politics, I think the public was generally willing to accept same-sex marriage by the time of Obergefell, given the limited protest that the ruling engendered. I think the public is still generally accepting. I don't think there's a strong movement to overturn the decision, although legal purists might see value in cleaning up the legal reasoning. In any event, I expect same-sex couples will continue to wed, even if it requires travelling to a different state.
The Roberts Court overturns precedents at a demonstrably lower rate than earlier courts, a rate that has not increased with recent Trump appointees. Sorry to break it to you.
What does public opinion have to do with the law? Have you heard of "blind justice"? Justice should be blind but it hasn't been since they added "social" in front of it.
I thought the Court lost its intellectual integrity in Bush v. Gore, but I was wrong. That integrity was lost with Dobbs, a case that had been taught and tested for half a century as the aw of the land. Roberts is aware of this; he knows that overruling Obergefell will be political and he wants to protect the Court from further political attacks. Maybe he will be able to do so but it's just as possible that he will not. Overruling Oberfegell will thus be an entirely political exercise. It doesn't matter what "the Law is," the Court makes it up as it goes along.
Obergefell also overruled a 50-year-old precedent(Baker v. Nelson, 1971). So was Obergefell also bereft of intellectual integrity? Or does caterwauling about stare decisis irrespective of the actual merits arguments only work in one direction?
Obergefell is wrong as a matter of Constitutional law but it is in no danger because the Court does not want the headache given the widespread support for same sex "marriage." Why take a case to overrule it when most states would recognize them? A momentous change to American life was made 5-4 but it has stuck.
The Trump administration is a Fascist, White Supremacy, prejudice bunch of grifters. Unfortunately they are trying to take all the progress America made, but we the people will not let it happen. Be sure to vote at midterms.
There is no realistic chance that the Court overturns Obergefell here. The petitioner is estopped from seeking such relief, as she affirmatively disclaimed it below. If this petition is what has you worried about Obergefell, it’s because you are being preyed on by people who want to milk money out of your fear.
Substantive due process, revived by the Warren Court, gives progressives the honor of writing the least constitutionally based jurisprudence on the books since the Lochner era. Progressives need to dispense with the fiction that the Constitution—a document written by wealthy White men, many of whom owned slaves—exists to uphold their interests. Luckily, there’s this little entity called the legislative branch that can preserve much of the noble rights enshrined by the Warren Court without conjuring legal fictions to do so.
The Framers didn’t put anything about abortion, gay marriage, voting, or whatever other SDP values liberals hold dear in the Constitution for a reason. And the EPC is a decent vehicle for protection, but Skrmetti showed this Court won’t take EPC arguments for substantive protections very seriously. Therefore, since amending the Constitution is basically impossible, state and federal legislation is the way to ensure we get protections and rights beyond what the Constitution explicitly guarantees.
When talking about what the “framers” had in mind, it is helpful to keep in mind how narrow that group was in terms of race, class, gender and wealth/place in society. They were relatively affluent white men of their time - nothing more, nothing less.
I've been pretty comfortable in saying that SCOTUS doesn't want to touch gay marriage wholly but would strongly prefer to add first amendment religious protections that would make it harder but not outright banned in some red states. Davis' case is not the vehicle for that but rather what Texas is doing to allow their judges to not personally sign off on a gay marriage likely is.
As well, Gorsuch and Roberts' votes in the LGBTQ workplace protections case makes me think they'd rather not have to parse out how discrimination of sex in marriage is different from discrimination based on sex (sexual orientation) in the workplace which they found was not legal.
I think you need to add an option to the poll. My vote is “yes, but not with this case” (for the reasons you noted).
The wording of the poll was designed with that in mind—it refers to “the current Supreme Court,” but not Davis v. Ermold. You should vote “yes” if you think the current Court—i.e., this set of justices—will overrule Obergefell.
I agree with you Evelyn.
Greetings! Much appreciate your post and you, as always, presenting cleanly arguments from both sides. Much of the media and legal publications these days take pleasure in delivering sound-bites / outrage to energize their active base, rather than deliver the facts as they are. Yet, putting that to the side, Obergefell very likely will not, and should not, be overruled in this case. I am not yet an attorney, but I am wondering how / to what extent justice Kennedy's recent comments on his book tour still stand and have purchase with the justices (reliance plus societal impact?) Plus, isn't there an issue here with the equal protection clause as well?
While I am here, I am also troubled with another part of question 3 in this petition, the "fiction" of substantive due process. If Kim Davis really wants Obergefell to be throne out, is it truly tactful to add such loaded terms into the question presented? Contrast that wording there to this: "Whether all pre-viability prohibitions on elective abortions are unconstitutional Take that for what it is, and what resulted.
Finally, unlike in the pre-dobbs landscape, has there been any movement by state legislatures (save Idaho) to express objection to Obergefell? At the very least, one can and did argue that red states had weighed in strongly in opposition to Roe / Casey before they were tossed. Has the same happened here?
In closing, I do wish that certain media outlets would take more time to study SCOTUS procedure / filings. I fear that an ignorance of such issues, plus a need to get more views, ratings and clicks, causes the media to craft provocative headlines on this issue that distort what is actually happening. Thank you.
."
Agree with John that Obergefell was wrongly and tendentiously decided, but the current Court will not want to waste any legitimacy on a question that has been decided in the court of public opinion and will likely deny cert. on the petition as a whole without comment.
Except that at the times Dobbs was decided at least 2/3 of the public approved of legal abortion. The court had no trouble then of dismissing public opinion.
The grant rate for a regular cert petition hovers around 1%. When a response has been called for it raises to 5%. Still vanishingly small.
I just don’t see how to count to the four necessary to grant cert here. I do see five plus to decide the question differently as a matter of first principles, but that ship has sailed. On top of the question of whether to take the case, I don’t know if there are five to overrule Obergefell. I could easily see the liberals convincing at least two, maybe three, to leave it in place.
That’s cold comfort to my friends experiencing serious turmoil whose marriages would be imperiled by a grant. But I just don’t see it happening.
Thanks for the interesting stats! And I agree 100 percent with your second paragraph.
Should’ve included my source for the stats: Bloomberg. https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/call-for-response-signals-scotus-interest
In addressing Big Questions, I tend to look from 3 angles:
1. Policy: what would be a good rule, and who gets to decide?
2. Legal/constitutional: what does existing law say, and who gets to decide?
3. Political: what will the public demand, accept, or reject?
All 3 are relevant, but should be considered separately, and point to the appropriate path to making a decision.
With respect to policy, I think allowing same-sex marriage is good, because I return to first principles: the (only) reason for the civil institution of marriage is to provide a legal framework for raising and supporting children. Although same-sex couples can't have their own biological children, they can (and do) have children by various other means: artificial insemination, surrogacy, and adoption for instance. It is in everyone's interest - the couples, the children, the larger society, to allow these couples to formalize their relationship and the attendant rights and responsibilities.
With respect to law, I think there's no good-faith argument that pre-Obergefell law required recognition of same-sex marriage nationwide, particularly as the federal government has no role in marriage law. I think there is a very strong argument that the "full faith and credit" clause (Article 4, section 1) of the US Constitution would require all states to recognize same-sex marriages performed and recorded in other states; this would have similar practical effect to Obergefell, but entirely different reasoning.
With respect to politics, I think the public was generally willing to accept same-sex marriage by the time of Obergefell, given the limited protest that the ruling engendered. I think the public is still generally accepting. I don't think there's a strong movement to overturn the decision, although legal purists might see value in cleaning up the legal reasoning. In any event, I expect same-sex couples will continue to wed, even if it requires travelling to a different state.
This court has zero respect for stare decisis so why not go all Dobbs on marriage equality.
The Roberts Court overturns precedents at a demonstrably lower rate than earlier courts, a rate that has not increased with recent Trump appointees. Sorry to break it to you.
Also zero respect for public opinion or acceptance.
What does public opinion have to do with the law? Have you heard of "blind justice"? Justice should be blind but it hasn't been since they added "social" in front of it.
I thought the Court lost its intellectual integrity in Bush v. Gore, but I was wrong. That integrity was lost with Dobbs, a case that had been taught and tested for half a century as the aw of the land. Roberts is aware of this; he knows that overruling Obergefell will be political and he wants to protect the Court from further political attacks. Maybe he will be able to do so but it's just as possible that he will not. Overruling Oberfegell will thus be an entirely political exercise. It doesn't matter what "the Law is," the Court makes it up as it goes along.
Obergefell also overruled a 50-year-old precedent(Baker v. Nelson, 1971). So was Obergefell also bereft of intellectual integrity? Or does caterwauling about stare decisis irrespective of the actual merits arguments only work in one direction?
Speaking of making up law as it goes along, can you name the standard of review Kennedy used in Obergefell's Equal Protection analysis?
A) Strict
B) Intermediate
C) Mystical aphorisms of the fortune cookie
I go with "C"
Obergefell is wrong as a matter of Constitutional law but it is in no danger because the Court does not want the headache given the widespread support for same sex "marriage." Why take a case to overrule it when most states would recognize them? A momentous change to American life was made 5-4 but it has stuck.
It will go back to the states.
The Trump administration is a Fascist, White Supremacy, prejudice bunch of grifters. Unfortunately they are trying to take all the progress America made, but we the people will not let it happen. Be sure to vote at midterms.
So boring....
Loving?
There is no realistic chance that the Court overturns Obergefell here. The petitioner is estopped from seeking such relief, as she affirmatively disclaimed it below. If this petition is what has you worried about Obergefell, it’s because you are being preyed on by people who want to milk money out of your fear.
Substantive due process, revived by the Warren Court, gives progressives the honor of writing the least constitutionally based jurisprudence on the books since the Lochner era. Progressives need to dispense with the fiction that the Constitution—a document written by wealthy White men, many of whom owned slaves—exists to uphold their interests. Luckily, there’s this little entity called the legislative branch that can preserve much of the noble rights enshrined by the Warren Court without conjuring legal fictions to do so.
The freedoms enshrined in the Constitution apply to all people, not just wealthy white man. This class warfare is such intellectual laziness.
The Framers didn’t put anything about abortion, gay marriage, voting, or whatever other SDP values liberals hold dear in the Constitution for a reason. And the EPC is a decent vehicle for protection, but Skrmetti showed this Court won’t take EPC arguments for substantive protections very seriously. Therefore, since amending the Constitution is basically impossible, state and federal legislation is the way to ensure we get protections and rights beyond what the Constitution explicitly guarantees.
When talking about what the “framers” had in mind, it is helpful to keep in mind how narrow that group was in terms of race, class, gender and wealth/place in society. They were relatively affluent white men of their time - nothing more, nothing less.
much ado about nothing. Obergefell ruling will not be overturned but it will be re-examined closely.
I fear that an ignorance of how to spell thrown (out) hampers my appreciation for ND's belief that Obergefell will stand
I've been pretty comfortable in saying that SCOTUS doesn't want to touch gay marriage wholly but would strongly prefer to add first amendment religious protections that would make it harder but not outright banned in some red states. Davis' case is not the vehicle for that but rather what Texas is doing to allow their judges to not personally sign off on a gay marriage likely is.
As well, Gorsuch and Roberts' votes in the LGBTQ workplace protections case makes me think they'd rather not have to parse out how discrimination of sex in marriage is different from discrimination based on sex (sexual orientation) in the workplace which they found was not legal.
I agree with Evelyn K, below; but I think in this particular case, the vote will be 5-4 to preserve Obergefell v Hodges.
Next time? Depends on when "next time" happens.