"The judgment piece alone provides a great basis to revoke the offer; NYU has a heavily Jewish student body with plenty of people with Israeli families and connections. Even if this person legitimately has an informed belief that genuinely leads them to the position they articulated (which I doubt), this goes into the "keep it to yoursel…
"The judgment piece alone provides a great basis to revoke the offer; NYU has a heavily Jewish student body with plenty of people with Israeli families and connections. Even if this person legitimately has an informed belief that genuinely leads them to the position they articulated (which I doubt), this goes into the "keep it to yourself, at least for now" bucket."
Very well stated. It's clear they have no idea how to read the room or weigh how their words will land. I don't think that they needed to keep it to themselves, necessarily. Go on Twitter, Tik Tok, whatever. But don't abuse your position as SBA president (an org that obviously includes Jewish students) to espouse your personal opinions on such a fraught issue.
"The judgment piece alone provides a great basis to revoke the offer; NYU has a heavily Jewish student body with plenty of people with Israeli families and connections. Even if this person legitimately has an informed belief that genuinely leads them to the position they articulated (which I doubt), this goes into the "keep it to yourself, at least for now" bucket."
Very well stated. It's clear they have no idea how to read the room or weigh how their words will land. I don't think that they needed to keep it to themselves, necessarily. Go on Twitter, Tik Tok, whatever. But don't abuse your position as SBA president (an org that obviously includes Jewish students) to espouse your personal opinions on such a fraught issue.